Wrestling Recap: Hogan vs. Warrior (Halloween Havoc ’98)

The Date: 25 October 1998
The Venue: MGM Grand Garden Arena; Paradise, Nevada
The Commentary: Tony Schiavone, Bobby “The Brain” Heenan, and Mike Tenay
The Referee: Nick Patrick
The Stakes: Grudge match

The Build-Up:
World Championship Wrestling (WCW) changed the wrestling industry on 4 September 1995 by airing the first episode of WCW Monday Nitro in direct competition to the World Wrestling Federation’s (WWF) Raw is War, kicking off the “Monday Night Wars” that saw WCW dominate for a staggering eighty-four weeks. WCW accomplished this by signing some of wrestling’s biggest names to lucrative contracts. with perhaps their biggest coup being signing the undisputed face of the WWF, “The Immortal” Hulk Hogan, after being wooed by promises of big paydays and future film roles. While his initial run saw Hogan going though the motions of his usual hero shtick, he reinvigorated his career when he turned heel, rechristened himself “Hollywood” Hogan, and ran roughshod throughout WCW alongside the New World Order (nWo). Despite being relieved of the WCW World Heavyweight Championship in controversial fashion, Hogan and the nWo continued to dominate Nitro, leading to his old rival, the Ultimate warrior, to sign with WCW after numerous disagreements with the WWF. The Warrior’s arrival had been previously teased with a lookalike, the Renegade, but the real deal finally debuted in WCW in May 1998, going on a half-crazed rant, forming the “One Warrior Nation” (oWn), and critically injuring Davey Boy Smith with a gimmicked trapdoor. The Warrior would haunt Hogan with ridiculous mind games and tricks, which resulted in a dangerous fireball botch in this match, which is generally considered to be one of the worst matches in WCW history and incomparable to their WrestleMania VI classic.

The Match:
I’m somewhat amazed that Hogan didn’t politic his way into the main event spot of Halloween Havoc, which instead went to Goldberg’s much-celebrated victory over Diamond Dallas Page. While the commentary team big up the Warrior’s “magnificent body”, it’s clear he’s less than “Ultimate” here and much smaller than in his prime. Still, the crowd seemed anxious for the two old rivals to lock horns once more and, after a brief tie-up, Hogan took the early advantage with a knee to the gut and some clubbing blows into the corner. However, while working over the Warrior’s wrist, Hogan was overpowered and trapped in an arm lock then sent to the canvas by a hard shoulder block. After recuperating on the outside and dictating the pace of the early going, Hogan baited the Warrior into a test of strength, muscling the Warrior into another corner and deliver a beatdown. However, when Hogan clasped his hands to the Warrior’s and forced him to his knees, dominating and mocking his opponent, the Warrior powered up and overpowered Hogan, receiving a gut kick for his efforts. Hogan continued to dominate, keeping him on his knees and forcing him to expend precious energy, only for Hogan to keep his grip on the Warrior’s wrist. An Irish whip led to them criss-crossing until Hogan planted the Warrior with a scoop slam. However, as Hogan showboated, the Warrior popped up and hit a scoop slam of his own before awkwardly clotheslined Hogan over the top rope. The Warrior quickly followed, beating and slamming Hogan’s head against the security railing, smashing Hogan’s forehead off the ring post after raking the Warrior’s eyes.

A plodding match with a strange botch and an egotistical win for Hogan.

The match quickly returned to the ring, where Hogan accidentally collided with the referee and then doubled down by dropping a knee on him so the nWo could interfere. However, the Warrior dodged the Giant’s big kick and took both him and Stevie Ray out, only for the referee to miss his cover over Hogan. A back suplex scored Hogan a two count, so he repeatedly rammed his knee into the Warrior’s spine and whipped and choked him with his belt. Though he missed his signature Big Splash, the Warrior avoided Hogan’s elbow drops and returned the favour by whipping Hogan with his own belt. As Nick Patrick reprimanded the Warrior, Hogan struggled with some flash paper, resulting in the flames fizzling out in his hands and completely missing the Warrior’s eyes! Undeterred, the Warrior hit two top rope axehandles, somehow busting Hogan open. Hogan then hit an Atomic Leg Drop, but missed a second, allowing the Warrior to “pump up” and floor Hogan with repeated clotheslines. However, when the Warrior tried to win, Eric Bischoff distracted the referee, and Horace Hogan surprisingly cracked the Warrior over the head with a steel chair. This allowed Hogan to get his win back, though, luckily, WCW officials kept the Hogans from setting the Warrior on fire. I’d heard that this was a stinker, but honestly it wasn’t any better or worse than most Hogan matches. It actually had a bit of energy, with Hogan berating and clawing at the Warrior with an intense hatred, though the story of the Warrior being this resilient, powerful force fell completely flat as he was on the backend for most of it. The fireball botch was embarrassing, for sure, and the interference was annoying, and it’s definitely not on par with their WrestleMania VI match, but I’ve seen far worse efforts from Hogan.

The Aftermath:
Despite WCW going to great lengths to sign the Warrior and get him back in the ring with Hogan, this was Jim Hellwig’s last match in WCW. The last of three, I might add. He showed up on WCW Monday Nitro to rescue the Disciple from the nWo and then left the company, and the wrestling industry, prior to a brief return to the ring for the Nu-Wrestling Federation in 2008. Unfortunately, even the cataclysmic error that saw many viewers miss the Halloween Havoc main event match couldn’t distract wrestling critics from tearing this match apart. It was labelled a disaster only surpassed by the Warrior’s bizarre and lukewarm debut in WCW, with both competitors throwing barbs at each other for years to come regarding their respective attitudes and talents. Still, after years of being estranged from and vilified by World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE), the Ultimate Warrior was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame, made amends with Hogan, and gave a rousing speech to his fans that became disturbingly prophetic after he was found dead the very next day.

My Rating:

Rating: 2 out of 5.

Could Be Better

What did you think to the long-awaited rematch between Hogan and the Warrior? Were you excited to see the Warrior in WCW? What did you think to his crazed rants and parlour tricks? Were you disappointed when the fireball spot went wrong? Do you think this match is as bad as everyone says? Were you happy to see the Ultimate Warrior honoured by the WWE after so many years of animosity? Which Halloween Havoc match is your favourite? Share your thoughts on this infamous match below, support me on Ko-Fi, and be sure to check out my other wrestling content across the site.

Wrestling Recap: Hogan vs. Warrior (WrestleMania VI)

The Date: 1 April 1990
The Venue: SkyDome; Toronto, Ontario, Canada
The Commentary: Gorilla Monsoon and Jesse “The Body” Ventura
The Referee: Earl Hebner
The Stakes: “The Ultimate Challenge” singles match for the WWF Championship and the Intercontinental Championship

The Build-Up:
On 31 March 1985, Vince McMahon took a massive gamble on WrestleMania, a wrestling extravaganza watched by over one million viewers that forever changed the wrestling landscape. Today, WrestleMania is a peerless premier wrestling event known for career-defining matches and iconic “WrestleMania Moments”, with easily one of the most memorable of these being this unprecedented contest between Intercontinental Champion the Ultimate Warrior and WWF Champion “The Immortal” Hulk Hogan. After years of Hogan being the undisputed face of the WWF and easily the most mainstream star in professional wrestling, McMahon wanted a passing of the torch to a new hero for the ages and so cooked up “The Ultimate Challenge” for the Hulkster. Born James Hellwig, the man who became known as the Ultimate Warrior (and, later, simply “Warrior”) started out as an amateur bodybuilder. After being spotted while training, Hellwig agreed to join a group of other bodybuilders (including Steve Borden) as a professional wrestling team. After touring the independent scene and teaming with Borden as the Blade Runners, the Ultimate Warrior initially made his name in the WWF by destroying competitors in quick matches. This culminated in a last-minute decision to have him crush reigning Intercontinental Champion the Honky Tonk Man in around thirty seconds, cementing his status as one of the WWF’s most popular competitors as much as his wild energy, chiselled physique, and colourful ring attire. With fans cheering the Ultimate Warrior just as loudly, if not more so, than Hulk Hogan, the stage was set for a showdown between the two after a confrontation at the 1990 Royal Rumble. Not only would this pit the WWF’s two top stars against each other, not only did both men stay as virtuous characters in the build-up, but this would also be the first time both the WWF and Intercontinental Championships would be on the line in a single match. The end result has gone down in history as one of the quintessential WrestleMania Moments as, despite the Ultimate Warrior failing to replace Hogan as the WWF’s top star, it represented a changing of the guard that would, eventually, change the landscape of the WWF’s main event picture.

The Match:
It’s funny to think about how fans gravitated to the Ultimate Warrior, favouring him almost as much if not more than Hulk Hogan, considering how similar their gimmicks and mannerisms were. Both men were larger-than-super superheroes decked out in colourful attire, both ploughed through opponents, and both had a never-miss finisher sequence with a ridiculous final move that never should’ve worked but, somehow, always did! Still, the Ultimate Warrior does stand out a lot more with his face paint and jacked-up physique; the guy was like a living action figure! Unfortunately, one aspect where they differed (as expertly observed by Ventura) was that the Ultimate Warrior would sprint to the ring, run the ropes, shake the ropes, and get all fired up and gassed before the match could even start! This was true here, on what would end up being the biggest night of Jim Hellwig’s entire career, though the crowd simply ate it up as they loved this guy…and it’s hard to blame them as he exudes superhero appeal. Of course, the crowd was at least 50/50 for both men as Hulk Hogan continued to get the same response as you’d expect, still every bit the living legend kids and adults gravitated towards, and the atmosphere of seeing both men in the ring was simply electric. Since both men were popular babyfaces, a rarity even nowadays, there wasn’t the same vitriol between the competitors as in a traditional face/heel dynamic, though the two still engaged in a tense stare down to start since they both wanted to be the undisputed top dog in the company. As the young up-and-comer, the Ultimate Warrior made the first move, shoving Hogan, initiating the first tie-up, and giving Hogan a taste of his own medicine by throwing him into the corner. Naturally, Hogan returned the favour during the second tie-up, with both men posing and playing to the crowd before going for the tired old “test of strength” spot. Again, the crowd loved seeing the two titans testing each other’s limits, which eventually saw the Ultimate Warrior overpower the Hulkster and drive him to his knees.

Despite the thrill of seeing these two titans clash, the gassed wrestlers spent more time in rest holds.

Of course, Hogan rallied and turned the tide, presenting both men as essentially evenly matched in terms of power and popularity. Though surprised to see the Ultimate Warrior power back to his feet, Hogan tripped his foe to the mat for a quick one-count and then the two titans ran the ropes looking for shoulder tackles and traded scoop slams, gassing themselves even more! The Ultimate Warrior then hit a stiff, clunky clothesline and sent Hogan tumbling to the outside, where he began favouring his left knee. Limping, clearly in pain, Hogan struggled to stay on his feet so the Ultimate Warrior immediately targeted the limb with sharp kicks, before the two traded eye rakes back in the ring. Referee Earl Hebner admonished both men as tensions rose, before Hogan forgot about his knee pain and unloaded on the Ultimate Warrior with big shots and the ten-punches and another scoop slam. Two elbow drops, a two-count, and a small package later and Hogan unloaded on the Ultimate Warrior with chops, a clothesline, and the odd rest hold just to catch his breath. Still, the Intercontinental Champion kept kicking out, even after a backbreaker, resulting in a frustrated Hulkster arguing with the referee and wearing his opponent down with a chin lock that just went on and on and on. Hogan then hit a few spiteful knee shots to the spine and a backdrop before returning to the hold, showing he’s not afraid to fight dirty, before the Ultimate Warrior caught a second wind. After the Ultimate warrior fought free, both men a double knock down gave them even more time to catch their breath, and both men struggled up at the same time. However, the Ultimate Warrior was in a frenzied state, shrugging off Hogan’s blows and sending him reeling with a headbutt and repeated clotheslines. His face paint all but gone and his adrenaline spiking, the Ultimate Warrior tossed Hogan into the corners and laid in some chops, driving Hogan to his knees once more before hitting a suplex and getting his first near fall. The Ultimate Warrior then continued to dominate the WWF Champion by grabbing him in a pretty weak-looking bearhug that was more of a cuddle than the devastating hold Ventura and Monsoon sold it as.

A missed Leg Drop and a Splash saw the Ultimate Warrior share the victory with Hogan.

Still, this allowed Hogan to do the time-tested “three arm” spot but, as you’d expect, Hogan’s arm refused to fall the third time and the Hulkster mounted a comeback with some rabbit-like punches. However, as the Ultimate Warrior ran the ropes, he collided with the referee, meaning there was no one there to make the count when Hogan tried to pin his rival after reversing a diving shoulder block. This allowed the Ultimate Warrior to hit a back suplex, but both he and Hogan had to settle for the visual pinfall and a slow two count as Earl Hebner was too out of it to make the final count. A back elbow saw the action spill to the outside for a slugfest, which ended when Hogan got rammed into the ring post. Once back in the ring, the Ultimate Warrior hit the Gorilla Press Slam (an impressive, if ungainly, achievement) and then hit his patented Running Splash! However, the Ultimate Warrior was too slow going for the pin, resulting in a rare finisher kickout and the Hulkster “Hulking Up” However, Hogan missed the Atomic Leg Drop (!) and the Ultimate Warrior splashed him again for the biggest win of his career! Hogan just had to power out at 3.1, though, and keep the spotlight equally trained on him by presenting the Ultimate Warrior with both belts and raising his arm in a passing of the torch. This was an okay match but, as ever, one bogged down by rest holds and plodding offense. Both men were so gassed at the start of the match that their blows and holds just came off as so weak and obvious stalling. The energy was there, however, and the crowd loved seeing the two share the ring and shrug off each other’s moves. I think this might’ve worked better with a big stare down, test of strength, unflinching clotheslines and trading scoop slams, and then a finisher-fest (with the Ultimate Warrior also kicking out of the Atomic Leg Drop), but it was okay for what it was: a spectacle between two titans of the company.

The Aftermath:
Despite the Ultimate Warrior’s win and the very specific requirement that the winner would become a dual champion, the Ultimate Warrior was forced to vacant the Intercontinental Championship, resulting in Mr. Perfect becoming the champion after a lengthy tournament. Surprisingly, Hogan didn’t immediately vie for a rematch and instead left to film the under-rated sci-fi comedy Suburban Commando (Kennedy, 1991). Though the Ultimate Warrior rekindled his rivalry with “Ravishing” Rick Rude and helped the Legion of Doom at the 1990 Survivor Series, none of these storylines benefitted him. His mega push fizzled out and saw him dropping the belt to turncoat Sergeant Slaughter at the 1991 Royal Rumble after interference by Sensational Sherri and the “Macho King” Randy Savage. This led to Hogan recapturing the belt and returning to the top of the mountain at WrestleMania VII, where the Ultimate Warrior “retired” Savage. Although the Ultimate Warrior fought with the Undertaker and was prepped to face Jake “The Snake” Roberts, Hellwig walked out of the WWF after demanding financial compensation. The Ultimate Warrior made brief (and infamous) comebacks in 1992 and 1996, but disagreements about money saw him follow Hogan to World Championship Wrestling (WCW). After a ludicrous tease regarding his presence, the Ultimate Warrior, more unhinged than ever, opposed “Hollywood” Hogan’s New World Order (nWo), leading to Davey Boy Smith being critically injured by a gimmicked trapdoor, a hilariously botched fireball incident, and one of the worst matches in WCW history as Hogan got his win back at the 1998 Halloween Havoc. After years of being estranged from and vilified by what’s now known as World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE), the Ultimate Warrior was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame, buried the hatchet with Hogan, and gave a stirring speech to his fans that became disturbingly prophetic after he was found dead the very next day.

My Rating:

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Pretty Good

What did you think to the “The Ultimate Challenge” at WrestleMania VI? Were you a fan of the Ultimate Warrior back in the day and excited to see his big win? Do you think the match should’ve been altered to play into Hellwig’s strengths? Were you surprised when Hogan kicked out of the Ultimate Warrior’s finisher? What did you think to the Ultimate Warrior’s title reign and how should it have been done differently? Were you happy to see the Ultimate Warrior honoured by the WWE after so many years of animosity? How are you celebrating WrestleMania’s anniversary this year and what’s your favourite WrestleMania moment? Let me know your thoughts and memories of this iconic clash, support me on Ko-Fi, and be sure to check out my other wrestling content across the site.