Dr. K's Waiting Room

The Date: 23 October 1994
The Venue: Joe Louis Arena; Detroit, Michigan
The Commentary: Tony Schiavone and Bobby “The Brain” Heenan
The Referee: Mr. T (guest)
The Stakes: Steel cage match for the WCW World Heavyweight Championship with both men’s careers also on the line

The Build-Up:
Easily one of the biggest missed opportunities in the wrestling world was then-World Wrestling Federation (WWF) chairman deciding not to main event WrestleMania VIII with the biggest dream match the industry could produce at the time, the “Immortal” Hulk Hogan taking on “The Nature Boy” Ric Flair. A falling out with World Championship Wrestling’s (WCW) Jim Herd saw Flair leave WCW with their World Heavyweight Championship, but McMahon was put off from pitting the two icons against each other after being unimpressed with the reception to their unaired matches and a preference for slotting Sid Justice into a main event role. While Flair went on to have a highly-rated WWF Championship match against “Macho Man” Randy Savage, Hogan and Sid put on one of the worst WrestleMania main events and WCW wasn’t about to make the same mistake two years later. Flair returned to WCW in 1993 and recaptured the gold, competing against old rivals Ricky “The Dragon” Steamboat and Sting, while Hogan dramatically jumped ship in 1994. Before he reinvigorated his career as part of the New World Order (nWo), Hogan largely continued the same schtick that had made him so popular in the WWF and immediately targeted WCW Champion Ric Flair, whom he defeated for the belt in his debut match at the 1994 Bash at the Beach. With the “Mouth of the South” Jimmy Hart in his corner, Hogan retained the title against Flair via count-out at Clash of the Champions XXVIII, leading to Flair putting his and Hogan’s careers on the line for one last shot at the gold at Halloween Havoc.

The Match:
It’s probably controversial to say but I’ve never been much of a fan of Ric Flair. I think it’s mainly because he’s always been from a bygone era and his peak was way before my time as a wrestling fan, when the grounded style and presentation was notably different not just to today but to when I started watching wrestling in the nineties. I’m a little more lenient on Hulk Hogan simply because he’s a larger-than-life icon of the industry but I’ve never been massively wowed by his matches as he had a very limited repertoire and very rarely deviated from what worked, meaning I find his matches quite repetitive. However, I will say that much of my exposure to both men was when they were in the heyday of their careers and wrestling in an extremely limited capacity, so a part of me is interested in seeing more from both men at their peak and against a contextual background the plays into their strengths, and even I can’t deny that Hogan vs. Flair was the match of the wrestling industry back in the day. Flair was the first to enter the arena for this long-awaited match. Accompanied by “Sensuous” Sherri and draped in one of his trademark robes, Flair exuded the pomp and grandeur of the classic wrestling heel from head to toe. In comparison, Hogan was his usual bombastic self; played to the ring by his awful “American Made” theme and accompanied by Jimmy Hart and Brother Bruti (all of them garbed in Hogan’s signature garish red and yellow). Hogan pandered to and posed with the crowd in the epitome of the beloved, indomitable wrestling babyface. In addition to Michael Buffer running down each man’s lengthy list of accomplishments, Tony Schiavone and Bobby Heenan emphasised that both men had made an indelible mark on the industry and cemented themselves as icons of the business, and to really hammer home that this match would spell the end of one of their legendary careers. Interestingly, the flimsy, rickety wireframe cage was lowered around the ring after the competitors entered, making for an unsettling visual as the ring crew scrambled to get it secured, though this ultimately milked the anticipation of the crowd as was common for Hogan matches. Also, the cage wasn’t really built or tall enough for climbing; it was simply a frame to keep both men in and ensure a decisive victory by pin fall or submission.

Surprisingly for these two, the match kicked off with a bit of a brawl. Hogan pummelled and clawed at Flair in the corner, despite Mr. T’s best efforts to separate the two, and sent Flair flying with a back body drop after unsuccessfully trying to ram the Nature Boy’s head into the wire mesh of the cage wall. A couple of weak-ass clotheslines saw Flair begging off but Hogan wasn’t having any of it. He stuffed his bandana down Flair’s throat and ended up partially scaling the cage to stomp on Flair’s chest in the corner! Despite the fact that the match was no disqualification, Mr. T got very hot about Hogan’s uncharacteristic aggression and the two got into a semi-physical argument that was all the opportunity Flair needed to take control following an eye poke to the champion. Unfortunately, the Nature Boy’s dirty tactics and trademark chops didn’t help him when it came to slamming Hogan into the cage wall. The champion powered out of it and smashed Flair into the mesh instead, then ran him back into the wall to shift the momentum back in his favour and send Flair tumbling to the mat with his signature flop. A low blow and a chop block to the back of Hogan’s knee saw Flair regain control, however. With Hogan down, Flair immediately went after the knee and leg of the champion, which caused him to clash with Mr. T as well. Flair finally tossed Hogan into the steel mesh and firmly established his dominance with a triumphant “Woo!” to the braying audience (of which the legendary Muhammed Ali was a member!) before striking with his patented knee drop. Incensed by the onslaught, Hogan suddenly made a comeback, launching Flair into the corner and the cage wall and then driving him head-first into the mesh like a lawn-dart, but Flair answered back with an ungainly double axehandle from the top rope. The match noticeably slowed as Flair sporadically targeted Hogan’s knee and scored near fall off an admittedly impressive suplex. He was so pleased with his commanding position that he made sure to stop for a bit of a strut.

The two superstar icons exchanged chops and blows in the corner, and Flair frantically tried to escape the cage when he realised he couldn’t win the slugfest. Hogan followed, however, and assaulted the Nature Boy using the cage before causing Flair to drop crotch-first onto the ring ropes. However, Hogan’s renewed aggression was shut down with a boot to the face and put him at risk of the Figure Four, though the champion countered into a roll-up for a near fall. When Flair tried to stun Hogan with some knife edge chops, the Hulkster simply shrugged it off and started “Hulking Up”. He crushed Flair’s hand, ran him into the cage wall once more and then started grating Flair’s forehead on the mesh. A back suplex scored Hogan a two count and, as Hogan again argued with Mr. T (who, the commentators admitted, wasn’t a professional referee so didn’t have the best technique), Flair again tried to escape. This time, Hogan repeatedly smashed Flair’s head off the mesh and hit him with a barrage of chops, only for Flair to shut down his momentum with a knee lift and a couple more running knee drops, this time to Hogan’s weakened leg. Flair continued to work over the leg and wrench at Hogan’s knee, again causing him to butt heads with Mr. T, before finally slapping on the Figure Four Leglock. The crowd, Jimmy Hart, and Bobby Heenan were whipped into a frenzy as Hogan writhed in the hold before mustering the strength to power out of it and to his feet, but Mr. T accidentally took a bump during Hogan’s big comeback. Frustrated, Ric Flair kicked at  Mr. T and Sherri tried to climb into the ring to help Flair out. Although Jimmy Hart succeeded only in exposing her ass to the audience, Sting intercepted her and got clobbered from behind by a masked man wielding a steel pipe.

Sherri leapt into the ring, which sounds impressive (and, admittedly, it was) but it ended up looking a little awkward as she barely grazed Hogan. Regardless, Sherri worked with Flair to handcuff Mr. T to the cage wall, which was a weird thing to do as it meant that the gruff official couldn’t make the count when Flair had Hogan pinned after a shot from the masked man’s pipe. Despite the odds, Hogan took his attackers out, showing no compunction about slamming, clotheslining, or tossing Sherri about before once again assaulting Flair with the cage wall. Flair’s counterattack proved futile in the face of Hulk’s signature “Hulk Up”. Hogan shrugged off Flair’s chops and staggered him with clubbing blows, dropped him with the Big Boot, and crushed him with the Atomic Leg Drop. Mr. T made the count and, just like that, Hogan retained the WCW Championship and Ric Flair’s wrestling career was over. Hogan celebrated with Mr. T and Muhammad Ali but was jumped by the masked man, who was shockingly revealed to be Brother Bruti! Hogan’s former ally then teamed up with Kevin Sullivan and the debuting Avalanche to assault Hogan, who had to be saved by Sting. Considering how big both Hogan and Flair were back in the day, this match was really quite a let-down. It was surprisingly physical, especially in the early going and when Hogan showed an uncharacteristic aggression, but it slowed to a crawl in the middle and there were way too many repeated spots, such as Flair taking a back body drop or the two slapping each other about while perched precariously on the ring ropes. One thing I hate about cage matches is when they fail at the one thing they’re designed to do, which is keep people out. Sherri and the masked Bruti easily interfered in the match, but I don’t understand why she and Flair chose to attack and incapacitate Mr. T when it significantly impacted Flair’s chances of winning. Hogan “overcoming the odds” was a story that had gotten old long before this, but the crowd seemed into it here and were happy to see him win, but it didn’t really land for me. For what should have been an epic clash between the two biggest icons in the industry, the match was plodding and basic and shrouded by smoke and mirrors, meaning the spectacle of their long-awaited clash is mired by an otherwise forgettable contest.

The Aftermath:
Following this Halloween Havoc match, Hogan held onto the WCW Championship for a record-setting fifteen months. He wouldn’t drop the belt until the next year’s Halloween Havoc event, where he was defeated by the Giant before forming the nWo later in 1996. Perhaps in a bid to continue to capitalise on both men’s iconic status, this match certainly wouldn’t be the last time Hogan and Flair faced each other. Between 1994 and 2000 when WCW shut their doors, the two squared off in singles and multi-man matches no less than 21 times in WCW alone! They also fought on an episode of World Wrestling Entertainment’s (WWE) Raw in 2002, were at opposite ends of a tag team match in Total Nonstop Action (TNA), and even captained teams of five against each other when the WWE put on one of their controversial Saudi Arabi shows in 2019. All this is to say that no, this absolutely wasn’t Ric Flair’s last match in WCW or anywhere else. In fact, Flair was back on WCW television a little over two months later, regained the WCW Championship on more than one occasion, and reformed his legendary stable, the Four Horsemen, to oppose “Hollywood” Hogan and his disruptive takeover of the company. There was even a rumour that the aging Hulkster would be coming out of retirement to face Flair in the Nature Boy’s true final ever match in 2022 but, thankfully (given not just the deteriorating physical condition of both men but also how the actual match turned out) we were spared that contest…until the next time Flair decides to lace his boots up again!

My Rating:

Could Be Better

What did you think to the match between Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair from Halloween Havoc? Do you think that their matches in WCW lived up to the expectations or were you let disappointed by bouts such as this one? What did you think to the ending and the odd decision to handcuff Mr. T to the cage? Were you a fan of either man during their WCW days? Which of their matches and moments was your favourite and would you have liked to see Hogan and Flair face off at WrestleMania as originally planned? What’s your favourite Halloween Havoc match or event? Whatever your thoughts on Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair, and Halloween Havoc, I’d love to see them in the comments.